The best comment writing recipe for busy readers

comment writing recipe

We are all time poor. We enough on our plates to worry about commenting on other blogs.

However, this could be a bad decision. You could be missing out on loads by neglecting this.

And if you think comment writing is time consuming, it isn't once you know how. Just like with all tasks, practice makes perfect and it gets quicker the more you do it.

10 steps essential for comment writing

"10 steps!" I hear your brains cry out. It may seem like a lot, but actually most of these actions will happen really quickly once you become a slick at comment writing.

It's just a method of ticking these off one by one until they become part of your subconscious. You will find yourself doing many of these without even thinking about it.

This is the procedure below:

1. Find and save good blogs

If you make an effort at the beginning of your commenting career to note down the best blogs to comment on, you will save yourself heaps of time later on.

Get at least five excellent examples under your belt at first. Once you become better at this, find the next five. See which other bloggers are commenting, and follow them to find more. Ask your friends for recommendations.

This is all part of developing a consistent process. However, variance is a good thing too, hence the suggestion to find new blogs on a regular basis.

2. Read, don't skim

Readers that obviously haven't bothered to read the post carefully before they comment stick out like sore thumb. They either miss the point or mention the wrong thing, and look a complete fool for doing so.

If you haven't much time, the urge to skim may be overwhelming. We are all guilty of this. But it will help you immensely with the next tasks if you read the post properly.

Of course the post would be much easier to 'glean' if it contained multiple subheadings like this one does. One of the functions of breaking up the text is to aid quick readers. It also shows the blogger wants to make life easier for comment writing.

3. Think of a benefit or story

Rather than just launching in (similar to jumping in at the deep end), spend a few seconds thinking about the main meat and two veg of your comment.

There are many commenters who don't do this, and as a result produce useless and unhelpful responses. Dredge through your experience for practical tricks and tips, or your experiences for a story or anecdote that is relevant to the subject.

Write comments that provide a constructive benefit for both the blogger and other readers, or retell a memory people can relate to in order to understand your point of view better.

4. Find the author's name

Ideally there are two names that should be involved in a comment. The blogger's name which you refer to at the beginning of your comment, and your name which you add into the submit details.

Names (identities) are important. They aid recognition, show you're human and help towards forming a mutual friendship or relationship.

Anonymous comments lack credibility, and no salutation at the beginning of the comment will not warm the blogger to what you have written. You will want them on your side if you want your comment to get published.

5. Validate or confirm

The first sentence should at least show you've read the original post properly. This is when you write a brief and concise sentence revealing the main point of the subject and whether you approve or disagree.

This isn't as easy as it sounds, hence why many commenters fail to do this. However, it is something that will improve with practice, so it's worth taking time at the beginning to make an effort.

This tactic of comment writing will increase the chances of getting your comment accepted. However, beware of repeating verbatim or stating the obvious while doing this, or the effect will be lost.

6. Write at least 3 sentences

Comment writing increases in success the more you say in your response. The one-word or one-sentence comment has no traction, as it does little to contribute towards the post it is attributed to.

Focusing on a minimum of three sentences will lessen the task as a chore. However, as you get better at comment writing, you may find yourself writing a lot more. A comment with more content is more agreeable for all those who are associated with the blog.

Once you get into the habit of commenting regularly, you'll soon find yourself writing more than the three sentence restriction. But beware of writing too much, as an over-long post may undermine the blogger or run the risk of being seen as boring.

7. Say thank you

Finally, if you haven't already done this in the first sentence, you could thank the blogger for their post. Especially if you have learned something new or you have been suitably entertained.

Avoid over-thanking though. Commenters who are overwhelmingly gracious or overbearingly smarmy run the risk of being seen as spammers. This is a tactic most spammers do to hopefully get their comments published.

If you have already expressed your thanks, try writing a brief summary of the comment instead. Close the state of play by drawing attention back to the bigger picture presented by the post's subject.

Hey, what about the remaining 3 steps?

If you want to know what the remaining three steps are to the 10 steps for essential comment writing, you will have to click on these sharing buttons to find out:

[sociallocker id="2831"]

8. Read and edit

It is worth taking a bit of time to re-read your comment to edit it before you submit it. Remember once it's gone, you can't retrieve it to correct something or add another point.

Use this opportunity to see if what you have written makes sense, answers any questions posed, you haven't repeated anything, and your spelling and grammar are relatively good. The last point will distinguish you from a the majority of spammers.

If you feel happy that you have put your point across well, or that your comment is sufficiently helpful or appreciative, it's time to hit the publish button.

9. Publish

After you have submitted your comment, give yourself a pat on the back and, if appropriate, start looking for the next blog to comment on.

Record what actions you have done in a Tracking Commenting Schedule so you can keep on top of your commenting activities.

Remember blog commenting doesn't happen in real time. Your comment is more than likely to have gone into moderation, so you are dependent upon the blog's author whether it gets published or not.

10. Return to see reply

Let's hope the blog's author bothers to write a reply. After all, it's only polite to respond to people who comment on your blog. And there is the added benefit of doubling the amount of comments as well, which makes the blog look more popular.

If there is a reply, read and acknowledge if applicable. It isn't imperative to keep the thread going, but if you can drum up a nice little discussion, this can be interesting for other readers and lead to developing a good relationship with the blog's author.

Even though blog commenting requires a lot more content than on social media, it is still possible to have a nice little repartee going on under a post, even with the moderation delay.


Alice Elliott
Check out these awesome related posts...
And let me know your thoughts about this post below...
  • You’re a tease Alice, but I can highly recommend being part of the Commenting Club. I’m learning so many tips to make commenting part of my weekly schedule.

    I like your 7 tips, especially the first one having regular blogs to read. That’s something I’m working on.

    What do you recommend for saving these blogs to read more easily Alice? Thanks.

    • Hi Tracey-Jane, thanks for commenting. If course you’ll get to see the other 3 tips as you’re already a member of The Commenting Club.

      I use the application Pocket to store any posts that attract my attention so I can read and comment on them later. (See this post It has the added benefit of storing them for reference purposes later. Once you know the blog will continue to provide posts that are worth commenting on, subscribe to their RSS feed (if they have one) or subscribe to their newsletter to be aware of them whenever anything new is posted.

      Alternatively keep a list of good blogs and make a regular entry in your schedule diary to check them for new posts to comment on.

  • {"email":"Email address invalid","url":"Website address invalid","required":"Required field missing"}