Ever considered writing a commenting policy?

commenting policy

We all value good comments. However, it seems you can't guarantee getting worthy contributions every time.

Not everyone is blessed with a vibrant commenting readership. But if you are, it might be a good idea to write a commenting policy to give your readers a guide to how to comment properly.

It is a way of thanking your commenters by acknowledging their efforts. It also helps towards getting more comments accepted and published on your blog.

Stimulate more conversation

The best way to encourage honest and on-topic comments is to give your readers a helping hand.

They need to know what is acceptable and what is not. You may think your readers would already know this, but providing rules and regulations gives encouragement and offers a sense of community.

It shows you really value their contribution towards extending the conversation you started in your posts. This provides a sense of security within your appreciation.

Why have a commenting policy?

It's a good idea to promote a sense of community with your readers. They will get a better experience of writing the kind of comments that have more chance of being accepted.

Another thing to note is you shouldn't ban any comments that disagree with your post. Accepting only nice and agreeable comments makes pretty dull reading, whereas some alternative feedback provides more interest and credibility.

Negative criticism could be useful and helpful, as it offers another point of view. It also shows you have a wide and varied readership who are prepared to have their say.

Setting the rules

Remember this is your blog, and therefore your reputation is on the line. If you value how you and your blog is perceived, it's worth laying down some rules so that your readers know how to behave appropriately.

After all, anyone who comments is a welcome visitor, but they haven't the right to interpose or take over.

Providing rules may put some people off. But that doesn't matter, since they probably weren't the right kind of commenters you wanted anyway. Anyone who appreciates you and your blog will value some guidelines on what you think is acceptable.

Unacceptable comments

These are the types of comment you could state will be deleted:

  • All types of spam
  • Comments whose only purpose is to solely promote the author
  • Irrelevant comments that go off at a tangent to the post's subject
  • Comments that contain offensive language, including profanity, abuse, threats, libel, being derogatory and offering misleading views
  • Anyone who attacks individuals and harasses others
  • Trollish behaviour that stirs up trouble
  • Lack of respect for the author and other readers
  • Over ingratiating or smarmy comments trying to gain favour
  • Anonymous commenters that are nameless or without identification
  • Unsuitable websites/blogs attributed to the comment

Permitted instances

Here is a list of comment types that your commenting policy could stipulates are acceptable:

  • Articulate, well-informed remarks that are relevant to the article
  • Comments that express a valid point of view
  • Comments that move the subject forward and contribute to the conversation
  • Valid explanations for any disagreements, preferably with examples to back up the argument
  • If absolutely necessary, one link to relevant content only
  • Offer to guest post if the commenter has a lot to say

Reserving the right

There are particular areas about accepting comments that you need to explain in your commenting policy, such as:

  • Edit bad spelling, sentence construction, or if the comment is too long
  • Delete sections that are inappropriate
  • Not publish if the comment is unsuitable

There may be some people who say I cannot edit my comments. But since I edit my guest posts to preserve the quality of my blog, I extend the same sentiments to my comments.

However, I may not edit all of them, just the really bad ones or the examples that really bug me!

Do you have commenting policy?

If you have any more suggestions to include within a commenting policy, please let us know in the commenting box below. Together we can create the best commenting policies that are suitable for all of us!

Please leave a comment below, we would love to hear from you!


Important GDPR stuff: before you submit your comment, you will be asked to leave your name, email and web address, so we request your permission to display this data within our comments. Be reassured this information will not be collected onto lists or used for any other purpose.

>